So here we are, post game release, and as of this moment I have played through the game four times. The first playthrough took me three days to complete as I was playing blind and really took my time to savor every little detail, the second was much quicker - around 11 hours I think... but there is a trophy (Lightning Emissary) for finishing the game in under 5 hours! But I'm happy to announce that I finished the game without any help or hints, if I got stuck I just kept playing until a solution presented itself ; )
I have to say that I was not disappointed by The Last Guardian in any way, in fact it exceeded my expectations! Sure, the camera can be frustrating at times but once you know how Trico behaves there's no need to climb it in those tight spaces, like narrow corridors etc. This is where the camera has a hard time trying to pan in on the boy. In open spaces the camera works OK. Players also complained about framerates, but I saw no evidence of this whilst playing my version, although I bought a PS4 Pro 1TB, so perhaps the game runs better on this console?
Note: The following contains major spoilers so if you haven't finished the game do not read this.
I have to say that I was not disappointed by The Last Guardian in any way, in fact it exceeded my expectations! Sure, the camera can be frustrating at times but once you know how Trico behaves there's no need to climb it in those tight spaces, like narrow corridors etc. This is where the camera has a hard time trying to pan in on the boy. In open spaces the camera works OK. Players also complained about framerates, but I saw no evidence of this whilst playing my version, although I bought a PS4 Pro 1TB, so perhaps the game runs better on this console?
Note: The following contains major spoilers so if you haven't finished the game do not read this.
Shrine of Worship style ruin (shot by Len Allwood)
The first thing I really fell in love with (apart from Trico of course) were the landscapes. I mean you just have to look around to be awed by the majestic towers and enormous arches surrounding you. Some of these arches would make the massive stone bridge in Shadow of the Colossus look small in comparison, which is saying a lot! Almost every time you look around the scene is wallpaper worthy, simply breathtaking!
Enormous arches tower above
Temple facades reach up to lofty heights
Intricately detailed stone towers
The enigmatic white tower! Notice the windmill in this shot
Closer view of the windmill
Here we see our first homage to Ico, a windmill perched high up on a rocky ledge. You see this when you first leave the cave and arrive out onto the sunlit ledge, it's the first time you are outside in the open air. The camera pans up to the white tower and the windmill appears, tiny against the enormous structures that tower above it. But I could get no closer to this windmill? I looked for it in all subsequent levels but could see no sign of it.
I was informed by a user named 'Tomi nator' that you can actually destroy this windmill with Trico's tail lightning! So it appears the windmill does have a small role to play in the game, although it makes no difference to the outcome of the story.
I was informed by a user named 'Tomi nator' that you can actually destroy this windmill with Trico's tail lightning! So it appears the windmill does have a small role to play in the game, although it makes no difference to the outcome of the story.
Sunlit ledges are beautiful to behold ; )
The other areas that really peaked my interest were the sunlit ledges we see at various points in the game. Especially the second one after you enter the first temple. A wonderful sad piano piece starts playing, aptly named 'The Forest' from the OST. Its soft melody took me back to my memories of Secret Garden in Shadow of the Colossus. A beautiful hidden garden oasis in the midst of an unfathomable wonderland. See here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TDUEboC1DUU#t=36m19s
Origin Story
In both Ico and Shadow of the Colossus we see an opening cutscene which reveals how both protagonists first arrived in their respective lands, the Castle in the Mist and the Forbidden Lands. But in The Last Guardian we have no such opening, in fact it's not until around 4 hours into the game that we finally see how the 'unnamed' boy ended up in the Nest via a flashback sequence once he has been swallowed by Trico.
Origin Story
In both Ico and Shadow of the Colossus we see an opening cutscene which reveals how both protagonists first arrived in their respective lands, the Castle in the Mist and the Forbidden Lands. But in The Last Guardian we have no such opening, in fact it's not until around 4 hours into the game that we finally see how the 'unnamed' boy ended up in the Nest via a flashback sequence once he has been swallowed by Trico.
Opening cutscene of Ico
Opening cutscene of Shadow of the Colossus
The Last Guardian cutscene - we see a village in the midst of a vast forest
We are inside a room with a small lamp illuminating the darkness
A group of children sleep soundly - save one
A turquoise glowing butterfly flutters above a sleeping boy
Could the turquoise iridescent butterflies have a connection with the Trico creatures? We see them fluttering around the barrels we feed Trico, perhaps there is some symbiosis going on here? The boy seems distressed, in a nightmarish state. It's like he is dreaming about the terror that approaches, a monster that will appear from the darkness. This ties in with Ico who had a similar nightmare during his unconscious state after being expelled from his sarcophagus.
The next scene shows the forest flying under us at an extraordinary speed, as if something is speeding towards the boy in his feverish state. A small patch of cleared forest emerges and the camera moves quickly towards the village.
An aerial view of the village
We get a clearer view of the village here
This is the first time since 2001 that we actually see what one of these villages may have resembled! We know both Ico and Wander came from a village of some sort, Ico was kidnapped against his will and taken to the Castle in the Mist, Wander set out on his own vowing to avenge his beloved Mono's death. So we can assume that their home villages may have approximated this type of medieval wooden style construction. However, we have no timeline to go on, for all we know the events in The Last Guardian may have occurred millennia before or after the events in Ico and Shadow of the Colossus?
Suddenly a huge bird like creature swoops down and lands on one of the houses
It pokes its head through the window shutters - red eyes glowing
It seems drawn to the boy in his feverish state
Red eyes glowing - close up view
Here I think something strange happens. The beast is focusing on the sleeping boy, the camera pans in on the large red eyes of the beast... it's as if the beast is hypnotizing the boy in some way, sending some archaic knowledge via telepathy to subdue him perhaps? This influence the beast has may explain how they are able to immobilize and capture innocent children for their nefarious purposes. Or to be more scientific, perhaps the boy already possessed a special gene that the beast was drawn to? Something passed down to him over the generations.
The boy stops fretting and opens his eyes - they are now red like the beasts
It's important to note that at this stage the boy has no tattoos, he is just a regular child like any other in his village. Only after Trico has ingested him do the strange markings appear on his body. It should also be noted that each time Trico swallows the boy you see more of these markings appear on his skin. Here is our first comparison to Shadow of the Colossus, as Wander gains more darkness from killing the colossi, his skin and hair grow darker, his features more unkempt and bloody.
Wander has ingested too much dark energy in Shadow of the Colossus
The beast gently scoops up the boy into its mouth
The beast inadvertently knocks over an unlit brazier which gains the attention of one of the village women to investigate. Here we see one of the village caretakers of the children appear with lantern in hand, perhaps she is a teacher or grandparent? She screams at the sight playing out before her, a monstrous head swallowing up one of the children in her care!
The children wake up and run wildly away from the beast
The woman shields some frightened children - aghast at what she is seeing!
The villagers are alerted to the danger and raise the alarm via a large iron gong
Inside some villagers threaten the beast with spears and torches
Trico is attacked
There are soldiers here with arrows and spears. One of them hurls a spear into the beast's upper back, causing it to rip its head out of the window and land on the ground below to face its attackers! But the villagers are too fierce and too determined, and they outnumber the beast, so it has no option but to flee.
The beast flies away into the night
The boy's father?
Here the camera focuses on one of the men of the village. He seems a strong leader, perhaps a noted warrior among his tribe. I think this is the boy's father as at the end he is the first one to pick the boy up after Trico delivers him back to the village (more on this later).
The village elder
This old man says the words 'Be among the chosen ones...' as if he is both sad and proud of the boy's fate. Here we see a comparison to Emon in Shadow of the Colossus, a village elder who holds great respect in his community.
Emon - the village elder from Shadow of the Colossus
Trico flies away into the oncoming storm clouds
Here another beautiful piano piece begins, much like the music 'In the Land of Happiness' by Kow Otani at the ending cutscene from Shadow of the Colossus, but I couldn't find this track on the official Last Guardian OST? Perhaps we need to wait for the full track listing to appear later on? In any case, I think Kow Otani's soundtrack for Shadow of the Colossus is far superior to Takeshi Furukawa's The Last Guardian soundtrack. There are some notable piano pieces that I love, but it fails to compare to what Kow Otani accomplished for Shadow of the Colossus in my opinion.
Trico flies back to the Nest with the boy held captive in its mouth - a beautiful scene!
Trico dives down on its approach to the Nest
Ominous storm clouds surround the volcanic cone like temple complex
Suddenly Trico is hit by a bolt of lightning!
And is stuck down from the heavens
Trico's tail is dismembered during the lightning strike!
This can also be compared to Ico. Both Ico and the boy are released from their captivity by a freak of nature. Ico manages to shake his sarcophagus loose and free himself, or could it have been an lucky earthquake that freed him? The boy is released from being absorbed by the Master by another quirk of nature, a lightning strike!
You will notice when starting the game that Trico's tail is a little shorter than it is at the final cutscene. This is because during the lightning strike, Trico's tail is cut off! It's hard to notice, in fact I only noticed this by going through the video frames one by one. But this explains why Trico's tail is shorter at the start of the game compared to the end. Indeed, when the armoured Trico rips off Trico's tail at the end cutscene, you can see it's the same size (length) that we see in this cutscene.
You will notice when starting the game that Trico's tail is a little shorter than it is at the final cutscene. This is because during the lightning strike, Trico's tail is cut off! It's hard to notice, in fact I only noticed this by going through the video frames one by one. But this explains why Trico's tail is shorter at the start of the game compared to the end. Indeed, when the armoured Trico rips off Trico's tail at the end cutscene, you can see it's the same size (length) that we see in this cutscene.
Trico falls helpless into the dark pit below
Landing hard on the rocky ground below
Here we see another Ico reference. One of Trico's horns is snapped off in its massive collision with the ground, just like how Ico lost his horns when he stood up against the dark Queen in his final battle with her. Wander also gained his horns at the end of Shadow of the Colossus, after he returns from his battle with Malus and once Mono retrieved him from the pool as a baby, he had grown tiny horns as a remnant of Dormin's dark influence. So the horns concept is prevalent in all three games, Ico, Wander and Trico. It also shows how half of Trico's helmet is destroyed, when it collided with the ground the impact broke part of its protective headgear away.
Guards carry Trico back to the cave
The next morning, a group of guards find the injured beast, having no idea that the boy is sequestered in its mouth, they move it to a secure location via a large sled. It takes eight guards to lift the heavy beast which they cover in a huge tarpaulin.
Trico covered in a tarp as the guards move it to a new location
Using a pulley system - they lower the beast down into a crevice
Trico is lowered down into the cave
Notice one of the guards accompanies Trico down to the cave floor
Trico lies inert on the cave floor - unconscious and bleeding
Here the game begins - with a drop of water hitting a small plant
Again, there is a comparison to Shadow of the Colossus here... in the opening cutscene, Wander arrives in an area that later in the game Emon and his soldiers also appear, after defeating the 12th boss (Pelagia), a cutscene shows a similar plant (in this case a fern) being hit by drops of water from the rain.
Rain drops bounce off a fern in the opening cutscene of SotC
Trico expels the boy from its mouth
The strange green bubble bursts - releasing the boy
The boy is now covered in tattoos
Here the game begins, but now the boy is covered in strange tattoos. It must be part of the process in which once placed into a Trico's mouth, a weird transformation takes place. Each boy or girl swallowed by a Trico gains strange skin markings that help the conversion process by the Master. This cursed tattoo idea actually first appeared in an early build of Ico, but at the time it was Yorda who had the tattoo.
Yorda's cursed tattoo from an early build of Ico
Early Yorda with horns cradling her cursed tattoo
Comparisons to Ico
As mentioned above, both Ico and the boy are saved from their respective fates by accident. Ico manages to free himself from his casket, rocking it hard enough that it fell to the ground breaking open. He was lucky that the supporting structure under the casket was so ancient that it finally failed, leading to his escape. In TLG the boy's escape was also an accident, this time due to a lucky force of nature - a lightning strike! Trico is hit and crashes to the ground far below, the boy was cushioned from the impact by being safely concealed within the beast's mouth. In both cases the boys would have ended up like all the other poor souls, being turned into shadow people.
Both boys are saved by sheer luck
Shadow People & Guards
The guards in The Last Guardian are much like the shadow people seen in Ico and Shadow of the Colossus, being ethereal smoke like entities, except this time with a hard outer shell of amour and turquoise glowing horns. In Ico & SotC the shadows are dark with a turquoise outline, and here the guards seem to be made of the same turquoise smoke. You can see this when looking at their legs, part of which is exposed, and also when Trico smashes them to pieces - they dissolve in a puff of smoke!
The guards in The Last Guardian are much like the shadow people seen in Ico and Shadow of the Colossus, being ethereal smoke like entities, except this time with a hard outer shell of amour and turquoise glowing horns. In Ico & SotC the shadows are dark with a turquoise outline, and here the guards seem to be made of the same turquoise smoke. You can see this when looking at their legs, part of which is exposed, and also when Trico smashes them to pieces - they dissolve in a puff of smoke!
Guards are ethereal smoke like entities encased in suits of armour
But I believe all these entities are made of the same stuff, being some kind of spirit that can change form at will. In Ico there are many different varieties of shadow creature from the large muscular bull like shadows to the smaller skeletal and spiky kinds. All have turquoise glowing eyes which Ueda reused in TLG for the armoured guards. The horns the guards have are similar to Trico's horns being turquoise, so perhaps the essence of the turquoise goop the Tricos feed on has some relationship to growing horns... however how this is possible is a mystery to me.
Four different kinds of guards
Shadow of the Colossus however had a different kind of shadow creature, being human shaped and with no turquoise glowing eyes or horns, so even though Dormin has horns, his dark minions seem to be something else, perhaps they were people that Dormin ingested and as such retained their human form, or perhaps these entities can't change shape? It seems Ico and TLG are more closely matched when it comes to the shadow entities.
Shadow people comparisons
Soldier from the opening of Ico
Although not very similar to the stone guards in The Last Guardian, I thought I would add this image to compare the design style of the guards used in Ico. Of course, we know the soldiers/guards in Ico are humans, not supernatural beings, but the headgear is significant I think. Both are covered in alien looking helmets with horns and I think the Ico guards look even more sinister as they have no eyes!
Guard's Doors are like the Black Pools in Ico
Once the boy first encounters the strange armoured guards you start to see these strange blue doors that they emerge from. They are always locked tight and seem to be part of the wall. When a guard grabs the boy it always tries to take him to one of these doors, much like how the shadow creatures try to kidnap Yorda and pull her into the dark portals they emerge from. In TLG, if you get close enough, you can actually see the door open with a bright blinding light beyond. What is inside these doors in unknown at this point.
Both Yorda and the boy are grabbed and pulled into a portal
Focussed Energy Beams
The Last Guardian's main item/weapon is a smooth black mirror which can focus a beam of light. Trico uses its tail to shoot out red bolts of energy to destroy certain materials, mainly wood and glass... it doesn't seem to be able to destroy stone. But this device comes in very handy throughout the game. In Ico, the satellite dishes focussed energy into a beam of light which opens the main gate.
The Last Guardian's main item/weapon is a smooth black mirror which can focus a beam of light. Trico uses its tail to shoot out red bolts of energy to destroy certain materials, mainly wood and glass... it doesn't seem to be able to destroy stone. But this device comes in very handy throughout the game. In Ico, the satellite dishes focussed energy into a beam of light which opens the main gate.
Mirror acts like the satellite dishes we saw in Ico
Ico Spheres Resembles the Master of the Valley
A user on Reddit named 'zionner' made a very keen observation which I had missed, he noticed that there is a remarkable similarity between the large electrical spheres in Ico which open the main gates, and the Master of the Valley sphere in TLG. Although not identical, they do have the same style of design, so this makes me wonder if the Master of the Valley is nothing more than a machine, not an artificial intelligence but more like the spheres we saw in Ico? Perhaps the Master is just a mechanical or biological machine running a program and has no awareness of its self or its surroundings?
If we compare these two globes we can imagine that the Master of the Valley is an updated version of the Ico globes, so this would imply that the events in TLG come after Ico and Shadow of the Colossus, once they had refined how the globes work?
Ico main gate sphere compared to the Master of the Valley
Push Towers
As mentioned in my 'Last Guardian History' blog post, Ico has to push heavy metal tower like structures along rails until they caused a switch to activate some other device, allowing him to move on. In The Last Guardian they serve the same purpose, only this time by destroying the sinister 'eye' barriers, allowing Trico to move on. See here: http://nomads-sotc-blog.blogspot.com.au/2016/11/the-last-guardian-history.html
Push/pull towers seen in both Ico and The Last Guardian
Climbing Ledges
In both Ico and The Last Guardian both boys must climb along ledges in order to reach new areas. Both games feature ledges that exist above huge chasms, one false move and you will fall to your death. Of course in TLG the ledges are much higher up giving you a terrifying sense of how far down the fall would be... I mean you can't even see the ground in most instances!
Boys hanging from precipitous ledges
Switches
In both Ico and The Last Guardian you use switches to open gates. So it seems Ueda liked this idea and decided to incorporate it into his latest game. There are two types of switches in TLG, one opens heavy metal gates, the other requires the boy to pull a long chain wrapped around a cylinder to open gates.
Both Ico and the boy must pull switches to open doors/gates
Chains
Both Ico and the boy must climb chains to reach higher significant areas. In Ico this was paramount as the game couldn't progress without him reaching these out of the way ledges. In The Last Guardian this is also the case, however one major change is evident! The boy has no ability to 'swing' on the chains, he can only climb up and down.
Both boys need to climb chains
Jars
In Ico and The Last Guardian you will notice a variety of empty jars lying around the game in various places. They appear to serve no purpose which is why I always referred to them as 'Red Herring' jars, as they entice you with their presence, as if there is something unique about them. In Ico all you can do is throw them against a wall and they break into a multitude of pieces, in TLG they don't seem to break, but you can throw them at the guards to knock them off balance, and there's a trophy 'That Hits the Spot' for throwing a jar or barrel at a guard 20 times.
Jars serve no purpose in Ico but can be used in TLG
Hanging Cages
Both games feature similar hanging cages. In Ico they were found hanging way down under the main bridge, that is the enormous stone bridge that extends once both electrical spheres at either side of the main gate were activated. In The Last Guardian they are part of a vertiginous climbing puzzle which requires the boy to destroy one of the hanging eye barriers. Both cages don't seem to have any purpose, that is they were never meant to act as cages for prisoners etc. So I was always intrigued why these cages were hanging suspended in these areas for no apparent reason. It seems their only purpose is to act as interesting platforms to reach other areas.
Both games feature cages that act as jumping platforms
Crates/Boxes
Both games feature crates or wooden boxes you can push around. In Ico these are used to activate pressure switches in the ground but in TLG they are slightly different, some having one diagonal crossbeam on each side instead of the 'X' design we see in Ico. Others are just a wooden frame which houses food barrels for Trico. Admittedly, these are very different kinds of crates, but both need to be pushed by the boys to achieve an end.
Both boys need to push crates
Floating Crates
Both games feature buoyant wooden crates that can be pulled or pushed in water. In Ico the crate is used to reach a chain in the underground water gears section (after he has fallen from the bridge and miraculously lands on the cages as seen above). In The Last Guardian the boy falls into a pool of water as he is pushing a huge vat of turquoise glowing liquid away from Trico. Note: Trico seems hypnotized by this liquid which appears to be the same stuff found in the barrels and the one unique receptacle the boy hangs on a chain in order to open a large metal gate. It seems this liquid not only acts as food for the Tricos, but also a regenerative agent that restores them to health.
Both games feature floating crates
Walking on Rafters
In both games the boy must carefully navigate walking on top of narrow wooden beams. In Ico this is apparent in the Chandelier room as he must climb high up to the rafters in order to reach the chandelier, at which point he jumps onto it, causing it to crash to the ground below. In The Last Guardian, the boy must navigate a series of high wooden beams to reach the pull switch that will open a gate releasing Trico, all the while hiding from the guards. There are also other wooden rafters featured in the game at various places.
Climbing rafters comparison
Ladders
Both boys have to climb ladders in order to reach a new area. Some ladders are broken providing no access, but most of the ladders are placed in significant places which lead you to the next location. Of course the ladders are far more detailed in TLG compared to the crude graphics we saw in Ico.
Both Ico and the Boy must climb ladders to reach new areas
Elevators
Although very different in style there are elevators in both Ico and The Last Guardian. There are three kinds of elevators in Ico - the first can't be accessed and are just for show, but they resemble the antique elevators we are used to seeing in old movies, that is with shuttered metal gates that you have to manually pull open before entering. In the image below you can see the up/down buttons recessed into the wall.
Old style elevators seen in Ico
The second kind is the elevator you take up after securing the Queen's sword. The only way into this elevator is to use the sword's sword to bypass the idol statues that stand guard at the entrance. You next take a second smaller elevator up to reach the Queen's chamber, again bypassing more idol statues.
Top down view of the elevator that leads to the sacrifice hall
Elevator tower from the outside
The third kind requires Ico to pull a switch in order for the elevator to raise or lower, these pull switches are found throughout the game. We see these elevators at the waterfall level and the Plaza level in Ico.
Pull switch type elevator seen at the waterfall level
Pull switch type elevator seen at the Plaza level
However, in the Last Guardian they took a very different approach. This elevator is far more advanced in technology, but one could argue, not as comfortable ; ) Here there is no need to use an item or pull a switch to gain access, you just have to move towards it and the door will magically open for you. Of course, this is not the type of elevator we are used to, in fact it's just a large cage... seems more like a trap than a convenience.
Strange cage like elevators in The Last Guardian
Geckos (Black Lizards)
As in Shadow of the Colossus, there are a multitude of geckos roaming free around the ruins in TLG. However, these are only the black tailed type, there are no signs of the white tailed lizards. What is little known is that Ueda also planned to put geckos into Ico as well as some other minor animals, but due to memory restrictions he had to leave them out. In the sketch below from the Ico art book you can see the first early designs of the geckos.
Sketch showing Ueda's desire to add Geckos into ICO
We can also see Ueda planned to add bats into Ico
Gecko lizards in The Last Guardian
Caskets and Bird Receptacle
In Ico the boy is placed into one of the 54 stone caskets lining the walls by the soldiers of his village and left there to meet his death alone. Luckily he escaped, but for all the other previous horned children they weren't so lucky. What happened to them is unclear, but the caskets seem to act as some kind of chamber that siphons off the dark energy in the children and transfers it to the caskets.
Remember, Ico had already vanquished the shadow spirits of all the remaining 53 shadow children (see video here: https://youtu.be/mplwjCTiFNQ), yet at the end cutscene we see the caskets shoot out bolts of white lighting into the inert stoney form of Yorda. So this suggest that the sarcophagi are the vessels that are used to store the dark essence of the horned children, much like the idol statues in Shadow of the Colossus. Whether the caskets store light or dark energy is confusing as Yorda is transformed into another shadow entity, perhaps it's like two negatives equal a positive? Yet she still remains loyal to Ico and in fact sacrifices herself in order to save him.
In The Last Guardian we see a similar process taking place in the final cutscene. Instead of human soldiers putting a child into a casket, we see a Trico regurgitate a child into a strange bird like receptacle at the top of the enormous white tower. You'll notice that this strange bird like statue resembles a baby chick, perhaps fooling the Tricos into believing they are feeding a young Trico? The child is encased in some kind of bubble, much like what we saw earlier with our Trico when it was injured in the cave. Interestingly, the bird head statue is surrounded by broken pieces of wood, as if the Tricos have placed them around it in some form of nesting behaviour.
Strange bird nest receptacle made to entice Tricos
The statue's mouth opens ready for another sacrifice
Another nest?
Some players have found what look like other 'nests' at various places in the game. The one above is just under the windmill you see when you first leave the cave at the beginning of the game. It's hard to notice unless you look closely - this one was found by my friend and collaborator Morlun91, but it seems there are others scattered throughout the game.
Another smaller nest?
This one is on top of the first 'Antenna room' you encounter in the game (credit to a Reddit user: coaron), but this pile of broken, jumbled wood seems way too small to be a Trico nest! But it clearly resembles the wooden nest we see at the top of the white tower during the end cutscene. Perhaps these 'other' nests are precursors of what we will see later on in the game? Or they could actually be real nests for other Tricos? Again, we are at the mercy of GenDesign and Ueda's ambiguity, leaving us (the players) to imagine what they actually mean.
The child is covered from head to foot in those weird tattoos
Here we can see where the barrel shoots out
Once the child has been deposited into the bird's mouth, a barrel shoots out from the back of the statue as a reward and flies up in a high arc for the Tricos to catch and eat. This would explain the multitude of barrels we find around the temple complex. Over the years many barrels have been missed by Tricos, or perhaps the barrels overshot the top of the tower, falling all the way down to the valley floor. This would also explain why some of the barrels are half buried in the dirt requiring the boy to pull them out. Of course, many barrels are found inside rooms of the temple or boxed together in crates, so obviously these barrels have been placed there for some other reason.
Room below the Master of the Valley is littered with broken barrels
At the top of the elevator we find ourselves in a large white hall littered with broken and decaying barrels. I wondered how these empty barrels ended up here? Most are almost intact which suggests they weren't chomped up by Tricos as barrels are completely shattered once a Trico finishes with them. So the only logical reason I could think of is (as above) these were also reward barrels shot out from the bird receptacle that have been missed by the Tricos, they fell through the spinning fan blades and were smashed open on their way down to this room, dispersing their precious contents to the four winds. By the sheer number of these 'missed' barrels we can imagine how long this reward process has been going on, perhaps centuries?
Towers Collapses at the End
At the end of Ico we see the Castle in the Mist fall apart and sink dramatically into the ocean, once the Queen is vanquished. This reminds me of the end of The Lord of the Rings, it was the Dark Lord's power that kept Barad Dur standing over the centuries, once his life force was scattered with the destruction of the one ring, there was nothing left to hold the tower together and as such, it collapsed into ruin.
Castle in the Mist sinks into the ocean
In The Last Guardian, we see the white tower starting to collapse after the strange 'Master of the Valley' has been destroyed, but later (after the credits) we see the tower still standing, although heavily damaged. So although the white tower doesn't collapse as such, the same idea was used in the final cutscene.
White tower falling apart in the final cutscene
Ico & the Boy Saved in the Final Cutscene
Both Ico and Trico are badly injured at the end of the game. Ico gets slammed against a wall after his final devastating blow to the Queen, his last remaining horn breaks off and rolls away covered in blood. Ico lies unconscious as the castle starts to fall apart around him, but at the last moment, Yorda arrives in her shadowy form and carries him to safety.
Yorda saves Ico at the end of the game
At the end of The Last Guardian in a very moving moment, Trico carries the boy back to his village, even though it is so badly injured it can hardly fly! It crashes into the ground and regurgitates the boy in a final act of devotion... such a wonderful scene. But the boy lives and sadly orders to the beast to fly away.
Trico saves the boy at the end of the game
Comparisons to Shadow of the Colossus
The first thing any dedicated Shadow of the Colossus fan would have noticed is the amazing similarity the room where we first find the mirror has to the pool room in SotC! That is the room where we pick up the items after the time attack trials. They are virtually identical except there is a low ceiling and the room seems to be like a freezer. There appears to be an entrance to this room that has been sealed off, but strangely it's at the East side of the pool whereas in Shadow of the Colossus, the entrance to the pool room is to the North. The only way into this strange room is via a small crack that the boy can just squeeze through, perhaps created by an Earthquake in years past?
Pool room from Shadow of the Colossus
Mirror room from The Last Guardian
I find it significant that both rooms in both games provide us with items! In Shadow of the Colossus we collect all the time attack items from the water in the pool, in TLG we find the mirror in this similar room. The difference is we only find one item, the mirror, but it acts as a skeleton (or master) key for a lot of later events in the game. Both pools have water, but in TLG it's not as deep, just a few inches of freezing cold water. There are also cryptic designs covering every square inch of the room, and most imortantly, a strange sarcophagus like structure.
Seems a giant was entombed here!
What could this strange structure represent I wonder? Could it be where Dormin was laid to rest? It certainly looks like a human form with arms folded over its torso, feet at the bottom and the head housing a circular depression where we find the mirror. Significantly, we see this structure in the ending cutscene, as the white tower is starting to collapse, the camera pans in on this unusual giants tomb. This tomb reminds me of the Egyptian and Viking kings of old, they were buried with their most treasured items i.e. swords, shields, gold etc. so here we can surmise that this warrior king (if that's what it was) wanted to be buried with its most prized possession - the mirror.
View of the giant's tomb from the ending cutscene
There is also a pipe leading out from the head of the giant ending at the far wall, suggesting perhaps that this thing is receiving something from another part of the temple complex? Could the sacrificial children's energy possibly be routed down into this thing? It's hard to tell as we are given no information about how the Master of the Valley distributes the children's energy. All we know is they are fed into the bird like structure at the top of the temple by the brainwashed Tricos.
Some players have suggested this is the grave of Dormin, or if not, a place where Dormin once lived in eternal sleep. If it is Dormin, then this gestalt entity seems inert in this incarnation of the story, and it would seem has no impact on the Tricos or the boy. The strange Master of the Valley seems to be running the show.
Mysterious 'Master of the Valley' entity
Focussed Energy Beams
In Ico we saw how the satellite style dishes focused sunlight to open the main gates, in Shadow of the Colossus the sword does the same job except its purpose is to find the next colossus, and in The Last Guardian the mirror has a dual purpose, it focuses light to destroy obstacles or open specific doors. All three games have the same source of power, just in different forms. Both the sword and the mirror feature an ornate cursor icon.
Wander's sword also focuses light
Mirror focuses light
Climbing Vines
In both games the protagonist can climb up vines/vegetation/moss. In Shadow of the Colossus this is only used at the Shrine of Worship in order to reach the secret garden, but in The last Guardian they expanded this idea and introduced multiple places where it is necessary to climb up to reach a higher platform.
Wander & the boy climbing vines
Petting Agro/Trico
One of the unique features in Shadow of the Colossus was the ability to pet your horse, Agro. It made the relationship that much stronger as you had a way to reward Agro after a particularly stressful battle with a colossus, such as Quadratus or Phaedra. Agro would nod its head up and down in appreciation ; ) In The Last Guardian GenDesign took it a step further as petting Trico is so much more satisfying! Trico mews and squeaks as you rub its face, much like a dog when you stroke its back or underbelly. It's a wonderful moment when you share this intimate connection with the huge beast!
Petting Agro & Trico
Spiral towers
There are several spiral towers in TLG, most are evident in the 'high wire' level where you have to climb up onto narrow cables spanning the massive spaces between crumbling towers, looking down into the misty depths. This level is very stressful, especially if you are afraid of heights! If you have a large television screen you can almost feel the vertigo climbing around this area. In both games there are broken sections of the staircase, revealing their great antiquity.
Spiral staircases in The Last Guardian
Similar spiral staircase at #7's lair (Hydrus) in SotC
Butterflies
As we know there are many butterflies in The Last Guardian, they are everywhere, especially around the food barrels, but what you may not have noticed is that there are also butterflies featured in Shadow of the Colossus. Strangely, they only appear in the final cutscene when Mono and Agro enter the secret garden (PAL & PS3 versions only). The other addition to these versions was the squirrel/chipmunk which does not appear in the earlier NTSC version; this is also true for the butterflies. So when Team Ico updated the game to the European version, they added butterflies and the chipmunk to the end cutscene. These butterflies are white, not the iridescent turquoise and yellow we see in TLG.
Butterflies in both Shadow of the Colossus & The Last Guardian
Geckos (Lizards)
In Shadow of the Colossus there are both white and black tailed lizards in the game. The white tailed lizards increase your grip meter slightly, the black tailed lizards have no effect, and as such are just the same as the other minor animals in the game, i.e. turtles, birds, hawks and fish. In the Last Guardian the lizards also seem to be part of the background as you have no way to interact with them. But I find it interesting that Ueda added them to the game, I guess he was just being consistent.
Geckos in SotC and TLG
Bats
I was surprised to see bats in The Last Guardian! You see them in dark areas of the game, for instance in the cave we start in and other underground temples. In Shadow of the Colossus they only exist in one place in the forbidden lands; in the caves leading to the 10th boss (Dirge). The bats are very similar in both games, except in TLG they have added turquoise glowing eyes and they also hang from the top of ledges as real bats do. In SotC, the bats are just flying around randomly.
Bats exist in both SotC and TLG
Circles of Light
When the Master of the Valley calls the Tricos, you see a wave of turquoise concentric circles expand out from both from the antenna source and the horns of the Tricos. Due to the conditioning of the Tricos, they have no ability to resist the call. You see this clearly when the boy is trapped in the rolling metal cage and the other Trico is attacking it; suddenly a low drone like sound can be heard in the distance and the Trico's horns reverberate with turquoise circles. It turns tail and disappears through a large metal door.
It should also be noted that the antenna on top of the white tower is identical to the ones we find in the antenna rooms where Trico is overwhelmed and swallows the boy. They appear to be made of a translucent glass like material which can amplify the specific frequency that calls and controls the Tricos.
Concentric circles of light emanate from the antenna in TLG
Main antenna is like those found in the antenna rooms
The other Trico is called by the Master
The same circles of light can be found in Shadow of the Colossus. When you shine the sword onto a weak point or a sigil of a colossus they both emanate rings of light. The weak (or vulnerable) points give off a black light, the sigils give off a turquoise light. This is interesting as it shows a balance between the light and dark forces held within a colossus.
Rings of light and dark in Shadow of the Colossus
Climbing Ledges
In both Shadow of the Colossus and The Last Guardian both boys must climb along ledges in order to reach higher ground. In both cases, the main tower plays an important role in the game. In SotC, the Shrine of Worship can be scaled by Wander in order to reach the secret garden; although not necessary, it's an integral part of the game if you want to acquire all trophies in the PS3 version. In The Last Guardian, the boy must also climb along precipitous ledges of the white tower to help Trico destroy two eye barriers. Both the Shrine of Worship and the White Tower are the main buildings in both games and act as the depository for both dark entities, Dormin and The Master of the Valley. Both feature cryptic symbols embossed on the outside of the temples.
Both games feature ledge climbing
Useless Ledges
One of the most disappointing things in Shadow of the Colossus were a number of climbable ledges that led to nothing significant. That is you would find what you thought was something that might lead to a secret area, you'd climb down some vines over a precipitous ledge and find that there was nothing special there but a dead end!
Three useless ledges in SotC with map references
In the Last Guardian there are a few similar ledges with vines that the boy can down down, but this time there is no ledge to walk on, the boy just stops suspended on the vines with a huge drop below him. So if I had to compare the two games I would prefer the useless ledges in SotC, as at least in that game you had something to actually walk on, in TLG the vines lead down to less than nothing... except maybe a nice view.
Vines lead to nothing but pleasant views
Ancient Ruins
It's hard to say which game has older ruins as we have to take into consideration when the games were released. In 2005 Shadow of the Colossus was released on the PS2 and as such, the graphics of the time were limited compared to 2016's PS4 The last Guardian. It seems everywhere you look in TLG there are ruins of some description, old and dilapidated buildings and towers that are crumbling all around us. Trico's weight causes many of the platforms to collapse as they are at the end of their structural life, which suggests they are many hundreds, or perhaps thousands of years old. So I would say from a visual inspection that The Last Guardian seems to be more ancient, but this is open to interpretation.
Both games have ancient ruins - it's hard to tell which is older
Both games feature collapsing structures
Soldiers & Villagers
The soldiers that accompany Emon (their leader) into the forbidden lands are armoured and equipped with specialised weapons, such as crossbows and swords. They appear to be part of an army that may protect their village from intruders or criminals etc. When Emon realises the ancient sword has been stolen, he chooses his best soldiers to ride with him and seek out the thief. Presumably, they followed the tracks left by Wander until it led them to the forbidden lands.
Emon & the soldiers from Shadow of the Colossus
In contrast, the villagers we see in The Last Guardian don't appear to be soldiers as they are not dressed for battle and only have crude spears, fire and arrows to fight off any intruders. But we can see that the weapons technology in both games is similar, suggesting there may not be a great time gap between the events of SotC and TLG. However, none of the villagers have steel swords or crossbows which may imply that they are simple farmers trying to live a peaceful life in their secluded forest village.
Villagers have crude weapons
Collapsing Structures
As mentioned above, in Ico the Castle in the Mist is destroyed by the Queen's departure and in the dramatic final cutscene, it sinks into the sea. In Shadow of the Colossus, another enormous structure is destroyed, not the Shrine of Worship, but the massive stone bridge that links it to the Entrance temple and the outside world. This theme is apparent in all three games and seems to suggest the passing of something, some great evil that has been vanquished from the world, or at least the beginning of a bright new era.
We can surmise that all three games are based on a history that was unchanged for hundreds or even thousands of years, an empire ruled by a powerful sorcerer or immortal being that existed by sacrificing innocent people and children for its energy and nourishment. This explains why we always see such ancient ruins in all three games, broken masonry, holes in stone ceilings with debris littered all over the place etc. These are not shiny new constructions, but rather we are seeing them for the first time at the end of their stories, at the end of their long existences.
Both games feature major structural collapse at the end
The Boy & Wander Comparisons
At the end of both stories, the protagonist is badly injured after suffering a long and difficult journey. Wander is so tainted by the dark energy he ingested that he is barely recognizable as a human anymore... his face is haggard, his clothes dirty and torn, his eyes have turned turquoise and he has grown two small horns. The boy is covered in dark tattoos which grow darker each time he is attacked by one of the guards, and at the end when the Master of the Valley is vanquished, he is peppered by a multitude of what could only be described as 'iconic shrapnel', that is all those weird symbols that the guards and the Master of the Valley use as weapons.
Wander and the boy badly injured at the end
Controllable Characters at the Final Cutscene
In Shadow of the Colossus it's possible to control baby Wander in the final cutscene after Mono picks him up from the dried out pool. You use the four main controller buttons to produce cooing and crying sounds along with his cute little baby gestures. In The Last Guardian, Ueda also used this feature as you can control the boy after he is regurgitated from Trico's mouth. One of the villagers picks him up and in a final desperate attempt to save his beloved companion, the boy whispers commands to send the beast away.
Baby Wander & the boy are both controllable at the end
As mentioned above, I believe this man to be the boy's father, but that's just my interpretation, for all we know he could be just some guy who happens to be brave enough to snatch the injured boy away from the jaws of the beast? There doesn't appear to be any kind of genetic similarity between them, but it's hard to tell as we see the boy as an old man at the end of the game (after the credits).
The boy (as an old man) and his father?
Wander & the Boy Saved in the Final Cutscene
In the same style as we saw above when Yorda saved Ico from the imminent collapse of the Castle in the Mist, Wander was also saved by the female protagonist in Shadow of the Colossus, Mono. After she wakes up on the altar she meets Agro and they both make their way to the back of the temple where she discovers a small baby lying naked in the stone pool. She must be totally bewildered by what she has seen since waking up in this strange land, as the last thing she remembers was being sacrificed and dying! But without Mono's help, baby Wander would surely have died from exposure and starvation.
In The Last Guardian it is Trico who saves the boy... a wonderful and emotional moment in the game for sure! Trico is badly injured after its encounter with the other ravenous 'brainwashed' Tircos - I mean it's tail was ripped off for God's sake! Yet after they have departed, it has enough sense left to search for the boy, finding him unconsciousness at the bottom of the well, along with the remains of what was once the Master of the Valley. Near death, it crashes to the floor and again scoops up the unconscious boy in one final brave act of loyalty! It will grant the boy's most cherished wish, and take his back to his village.
Baby Wander and the boy are saved at the end
Shrine of Worship & the White Tower
Both Shadow of the Colossus and The Last Guardian feature an enormous tower (or temple) as the main building where all events coalesce at the end of the game. However, the Shrine of Worship, as massive as it is pales into significance against the grandeur and size of the white tower. This structure is truly beyond imagining in scale and architectural reality... it really seems to defy any of our known laws of physics! Of course I have no way to measure the height of the white tower, but if I ever get the chance, I can guarantee it will be at least twice or three times the height of the Shrine of Worship.
Shrine of Worship & the white tower
Below we see the boy hanging onto Trico's tail when we reach the elevator at the top of the white tower, below him it doesn't seem that far down... in fact if you look close enough you can see the bottom. I've tried to drop down there but the game resets, so it's too far for the boy to fall. But there is something down there in the very centre of the circular floor that seems to pulsate with light, glowing on and off at intervals! If you shoot this debris with the mirror you will see that it's just the remains of the guards that have fallen into the pit. The floor is concave so the remains of the guards will always roll down into the centre of the pit.
The remains of the destroyed guards far below
Unique to The Last Guardian
Compared to Team Ico's previous two games, The Last Guardian has some unique additions that only apply to this game, that is, they have no precedence in Ico or Shadow of the Colossus. Of course it makes sense that Ueda would add new features to his latest game as he had a lot more memory to play around with using the PS4 platform. But even so, we can see in some new additions a resemblance to his two previous games.
Stain Glass Eye Barriers
Unique to The Last Guardian are the strange 'eye' designs that are littered about the temple complex. They remind me of the stain glass windows we see in churches to impress their parishioners, so it makes sense that these eye barriers might have a religious meaning to them. Perhaps they are in some way praising the Master of the Valley? Or perhaps they have no meaning at all, just a device to frighten the Tricos?
They are found in all areas, some at ground level, some placed on walls, others mounted on elaborate trolleys and some hanging suspended high above on cables. A few of these symbols seemed to have fallen down and landed on the ground below, which is why the boy finds some already broken at ground level. Conveniently, they have handles which allows him to push them over the edge into the vast void below. Note: The stained-glass eyes were inspired by objects hung in Japanese rice paddies to keep crows away.
Stain glass eye barriers arranged to scare off the Tricos
As mentioned in my previous blog post about the history of The Last Guardian there is a similar eye design in Shadow of the Colossus (credit to Reddit user coaron). Of course this is just a nondescript wall texture found at #15's desert temple and in no way has any significance to the game, so I think any similarities here are spurious at best.
Strange 'Eye' designs seen in Shadow of the Colossus
The Black Mirror
One of the most interesting elements of The Last Guardian is the strange black mirror we receive at the start of the game. This is unlike anything we have seen before, both in style and design. In both earlier games, the only item we received (beyond what we start with) was a crude wooden stick. The mirror is something completely new and amazing as it has the ability to blast open doors (via Trico's tail) and also turn the guards back into their dormant state. That is, when you shine the mirror's reticle onto one of the armoured guards, they suddenly stop and revert to their original 'null' state. You can see these null states in the level where the boy has to navigate narrow wooden beams above the guards who look like a circular metal disc with their helmet (head) protruding above.
Guards in their dormant 'null' state
If you think about it, the guards in their 'null' state could be compared to the colossi before Wander triggers them. They had existed in their arenas for centuries (perhaps millennia) before Wander arrived, waiting out the eons until someone intruded into their domain. The armoured guards seem to behave in the same way.
The mirror is also used as a key to open and control various mechanisms in the white tower, such as opening the front gate, controlling the elevator and stopping the huge fan that controls the main antenna. Without this item, Trico and the boy would have had no chance to enter and destroy the Master of the Valley, and would have been forever trapped in the Nest.
The mirror is buried in the earth until it is discovered by some children of the village
This is the one detail in the game that I thought was a little hard to believe. As we know, the mirror was lodged in the earth when Trico regurgitated the boy at the end cutscene, there it lay for uncounted years until the next generation of children found it by chance. Perhaps a heavy rainstorm eroded the soil, exposing this ancient artifact? But surely the boy - once recovered from his long ordeal would have gone searching for it?
I mean he had a full lifetime to consider the ramifications of his amazing experience with his beloved and enormous companion Trico! Surely, during his long years living at the village he would have gone searching for the mirror? All he had to do was to dig a little into the soil where he was found by the villagers when he was a boy. His amazing experience would have been the focus of the villager's lore for generations to come, a chosen one that was actually returned to his home!
Yet we don't see this? It's as if he boy has no interest in his childhood experience, it's only by a chance discovery by the next generation of some children that we finally rediscover this very important artifact. Then, and only then, does the boy, now an old man realise the importance of the discovery! He cleans the mirror back to its original sheen - a perfect uncontaminated piece of technology, unable to be corrupted by time or ware...
The mirror also acts as a master key to operate and open various devices
Strange Sphere
Below we see this strange sphere jutting out from a completely separate room in the temple complex, far removed from the mirror room that has the same cryptic markings. What is this sphere doing here and what is its purpose I wonder? It seems to be part of the same technology as the mirror room, the entombed giant and the white tower, but its location makes no sense to me. In fact, apart from the mirror room and the white tower there are no other examples that have the same markings in the game that I could find.
So this sphere seems to be significant in some way. There are a couple of narrow pipes leading from it into the adjacent walls, but apart from that it looks like just another random thing in which the boy has to use in order to reach the bottom of the chamber. In fact, you can bypass the sphere altogether and jump straight to the hanging cage next to it. Perhaps this is a stone rendition of the Master of the Valley, like an idol statue that could be worshipped?
Stone statue of the Master of the Valley?
Another globe - this one looks metallic
When you are being chased by the other Trico at the 'rolling cage' area, the boy has to make his way down a couple of ladders and through a hallway that leads to a large well shaft. If you look up here you will see this metal globe suspended above. Could this be another representation of the Master of the Valley? Or does it have another purpose, perhaps an astronomical globe of the Earth?
Early image of the metal globe
Here we see the same globe from an early screenshot (circa 2011) which reveals some more details. It appears to have some dark and light patches which would strengthen the argument that this is a globe of the Earth and not the Master of the Valley, however until we can get a better look at the globe in the well shaft this will have to remain an open question for now.
Stone globe on pedestal
There are also these strange spheres mounted atop ornate stone pedestals which may or may not represent the Master of the Valley? Perhaps it's just the ancient architect's design choice xD. But the sphere is carved with cryptic symbols, so who knows? I find it interesting that the pedestal has what looks like an outlet that perhaps at one time was used to collect water? The well the boy climbs out of to reach this area is nearby, so we can imagine that it was once possible to draw water here.
Lifting Door Beams
A few doors are barred by heavy wooden beams that the boy has to lift with both hands in order to remove them. You can see how heavy they are by how the boy struggles to lift them. This is another unique feature that only appears in The Last Guardian.
Heavy wooden beams must be removed
Strange Glowing Turquoise Vessel
As revealed in the demo videos and images released for the game in years past, we had always seen this unique large pot/jar that the boy carries up some stairs. It's an unusual item as it only appears once in the game which suggests to me it was an early idea that somehow made it into the final release of the game. You find it hanging on a chain which you can lower by pulling a switch. Although the vessel is almost as large as the boy, it seems remarkably lightweight, as the boy has no problem lifting and carrying it.
Another anomaly about this item is that it appears to hold the strange glowing turquoise liquid that seems to be leaking out over the rim, yet if you drop or throw it anywhere, the liquid doesn't spill out. It's like the liquid is a solid mass that has hardened and become part of the vessel that contains it. The glowing turquoise quality of the substance appears to be the same stuff we find in the barrels we feed to Trico, but why this large vessel exists on its own and is found nowhere else is just another mystery.
Unique vessel holds mysterious glowing liquid
Food barrels
In the early trailers and images of the game (since 2009) we always saw how the boy would feed Trico with the barrels. But what do the barrels contain? Is it one of the kidnapped children that has been minced and refined into a sick human soup, another incarnation of the 'Soylent green' idea? It has been suggested that the body of the child is processed into food for the Tricos, but the 'soul' or life force of the child is channelled to either the entombed giant in the mirror room or the Master of the Valley.
But there is a lot of ancient mining equipment scattered around the temple in various places, great rail tracks with metal carriages, the remains of refineries etc. It seems there was a great effort to mine and process something in the past, perhaps this is where the turquoise substance comes from?
Boy carrying two stacked barrels - very tricky to pull off
Elevator Cages
I mentioned these above in the Ico section but as these strange cages are so unique, I thought I would add them here also, even though you only see them in one part of the temple. They appear to be based on the same weird alien technology we see in the white tower, with glowing icons powering up as soon as the boy walks onto the circular platform. As soon as the boy approaches one they automatically open, then close once the boy steps inside. You hear a low droning sound associated with their activation. But as advanced as these cages are they look simple from the outside, just a metal cage attached to a chain.
Strange alien looking elevator cages
Trico's Call of Nature
One of the stranger aspects of The Last Guardian is the fact that Trico can poop! I guess Ueda put this into the game as all mammals (including humans) take this for granted but avoid discussing it, but when our pets release their bowels we think nothing of it, we just see it as a natural thing animals do.
Trico's droppings
In one of the earlier trailers you see Trico raking the ground with its hind legs, throwing up dust and causing the boy to lose balance... this is exactly how cats behave after they expel their waste... they scratch the ground with their back legs to cover up and bury their leavings, very neat and tidy compared to a dog who just craps anywhere then moves on. The boy can even pick up and carry Trico's leavings, which appear to be translucent balls of liquid. Whether they smell or not isn't revealed in the game... the boy seems unperturbed by the experience ; ) See video here: https://youtu.be/DSO_PeuwYU4
Trico raking the ground behind it
There are some stacked rocks in Shadow of the Colossus that some players used to joke about being colossi droppings! It was never a serious subject, but once you visit these rock formations you can see how they might be interpreted as such.
Rocks look like colossi droppings ; )
Pull Heads off the Guards
Once a guard has been knocked down by Trico you can run up to it and grab hold of its head (helmet) and by holding down the CIRCLE button can pull it free. I've found that most of the time when I attempt to pull a head off, Trico arrives and smashes the guard to pieces before I have a chance to finish it off! But I did receive the 'Losing Their Minds' trophy which requires removing 10 or more heads ; )
Pulling heads off guards
So I wondered if this could be a weird homage to the earliest (OPM) demo of the Shadow of the Colossus? In that demo, and only that demo you can find an untextured and unfinished model of Mono in the secret garden. It's one of the rare glimpses of Team Ico's test areas that was not supposed to be seen by players. But thanks to a glitch in the demo, it was possible to climb all the way up to this inaccessible area and see this unfinished model of Mono. She is headless with her arms extended in the so called T stance.
Headless Mono model from the OPM demo
Vertiginous Heights
One of the most memorable experiences of The Last Guardian for me were the immense heights the boy had to endure in order to help Trico move on. Some of the high wire cable crossings actually caused a virtual 'vertigo' for me xD. Especially in the area where the boy has to navigate a series of high wire cages, metal platforms and cables to reach the suspended 'eye barriers' that restrict Tricos movements. This is unique to TLG as the highest we ever achieved in Shadow of the Colossus was riding the back of the two flying colossi, Avion and Phalanx. But compared to TLG there is no comparison... the immense depths we see below us in TLG really drives home how high up we are, and how far we have to fall if we slip or make a mistake!
Dizzying heights must be braved to help Trico
Same view from Trico's perspective (not seen in game)
Climb up to Higher Levels via Trico
This feature is unique to The Last Guardian, sure we could climb up the colossi in Shadow of the Colossus, but there was never any way to jump up to a higher platform from a colossus. But in TLG it's different. We have our own stupendous colossus that obeys our commands! If only we could command the colossi in SotC, think of the possibilities! The sad thing is that TLG is in essence a linear game, we are forced forward via Trico's movements, this is not an open world game like SotC, it's much more like Ico in style as we are limited to the design of the temple complex and where Trico can move.
The boy needs Trico to climb higher
Pull out Spears from Trico
Trico has two spears lodged in its body when the boy first wakes up in the cave next to the beast. This concept is based on the old Greek myth of Androcles and the Lion. The story goes like this: 'Poor Androcles was in despair; he had not strength to rise and run away, and there was the lion coming upon him. But when the great beast came up to him instead of attacking him it kept on moaning and groaning and looking at Androcles, who saw that the lion was holding out his right paw, which was covered with blood and much swollen. Looking more closely at it Androcles saw a great big thorn pressed into the paw, which was the cause of all the lion's trouble. Plucking up courage he seized hold of the thorn and drew it out of the lion's paw, who roared with pain when the thorn came out, but soon after found such relief from it that he fawned upon Androcles and showed, in every way that he knew, to whom he owed the relief.'
So we can see where Ueda might have gotten his idea of Trico being helpless and wounded and why it 'fawns' upon the boy instead of eating him! It's an ancient concept, help given will be rewarded with help, or more colloquially 'You scratch my back and I'll scratch yours'. Ironically, the first two spears the boy pulls from Trico's body are the same ones thrown by his village friends to try and save him from the beast!
The boy must gain Trico's trust by removing spears
Crawling through Tunnels
In The Last Guardian the boy is forced to crawl through narrow tunnels in order to reach new levels. There's no evidence of this feature in Ico, but in Shadow of the Colossus there are a couple of drains in the secret garden where this is possible, but only by hacking the game and even then it's very glitchy... not worth even mentioning really. But the tunnels are so narrow that only the boy is small enough to squeeze through.
Narrow tunnels that only the boy can crawl through
Antennas
The main antenna in The Last Guardian is featured in the final cutscene, it is activated once Trico and the boy reach the top of the white tower. Somehow the Master of the Valley senses that there is a danger to its existence so it sends out a homing signal which draws in the other Tricos. At first our Trico seems to be in no danger, one of the Tricos smells our Trico then moves away, but another notices the boy and reacts violently! It starts to attack the boy, at which time our Trico steps in and protects him. This draws the attention of all the other Tricos, and suddenly our Trico is outnumbered and in very great danger.
Master of the Valley sends out a homing signal to the Tricos
Trico's Die!
Once the main tower antenna has been destroyed by the amputated Trico tail, the Master of the Valley implodes and almost kills the boy in its death throws, as so much debris is expelled when it is destroyed. The boy is ravaged by a multitude of shrapnel thrown off by the Master of the Valley. Up above, we see the other (brainwashed) Tricos stop attacking 'our' Trico and look around as if they are experiencing their first gasp of freedom in as long as they can remember, many have forgotten what their life was like before...
The shift in their consciousness is so puissant that they have no means to deal with this new found realization of what they are or why they exist! Overwhelmed by this new revelation, they all lose their mental faculties and drop like stones from the heavens. We see the Tricos on the edge of the white tower start to drop, while the others flying around just stop and begin to fall down like so many raindrops in a heavy downpour of rain.
Tricos drop from the sky once the Master of the Valley has been destroyed!
Trico Statues
It appears there may have only been 16 Tricos in the game, our Trico, the other Trico we see that fights us, and eight more we see in the final cutscene (makes 10) and six more we don't see. This was noticed by a user 'Nightwind's Top Gaming' who found an image in the TLG artbook showing an early sketch of the Nest with 16 Trico statues perched on the outer rim of the crater.
See video here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0OoHT2ixcRk&t=0s
16 Trico statues around the rim of the crater
So I was wondering if there is any relationship between the Trico statues we see scattered around the temple complex and the Tricos themselves? Could they be the same golem type entities we see in Shadow of the Colossus? That is, when a Trico dies does it revert back to clay and stone like the colossi did? As we don't actually see any Trico remains this has to remain an open question for now, but perhaps some of the broken statues we see might be the remains of dead Tricos... or they could just be fallen Trico statues.
GenDesign website shows a Trico skeleton
On the GenDesign website you see a skeleton of Trico suggesting this was indeed a living, breathing creature and not an animated golem. We don't find any evidence of these skeletons in the game, but if it's part of GenDesign's website then we can be confident that the Tricos don't revert into a pile of stone, as we saw in Shadow of the Colossus.(Credit to tahk0).
Trico statues can be found in various parts of the game
We also find fallen and broken Trico statues
Update: There are actually 32 Trico statues around the rim of the volcano/crater, not 16 as was shown in the above Collector's edition art book (double the amount of colossi in SotC). It was Morlun91 who drew my attention to this, so I decided to test it by running around the rim of the white tower and taking hi-res snapshots of each statue from a distance. As long as you stay away from Trico you can run all the way around the rim of the tower without triggering the cutscenes. Interestingly, a Reddit user (jira89) noticed that there are also 32 birds at the final climatic cutscene in Ico.
32 Trico statues line the rim of the Nest complex
Download hi-res image here: https://mega.nz/#!RtlkkZ4Y!ozhL-iCyhuUGu5hfrsMB4MjOgiXqEd0Et-pH1xs0XhE
32 birds at the final cutscene in Ico
Fighting Tricos
The one thing fans always wanted to see in Shadow of the Colossus was a fight between two colossi! In The Last Guardian we finally see a what could only be described as a battle between two colossal creatures! Trico and the 'other' helmeted Trico. However, the battle seems one sided, with the other Trico having the upper hand. Our Trico doesn't seem to have a chance against this superior armoured Trico, and indeed needs the boy's help in order to survive. There are several stages to the fight, all requiring the boy's help in order to save Trico. However, I think seeing two of the humanoid colossi battling each other would have been even more exciting!
Battling Tricos
Photoshop montage of two colossi fighting each other
Guard's Weapon
The stone guards close their hands together in order to throw out a multitude of archaic symbols which seem to penetrate and subdue the boy. Only by mashing the controller buttons can you escape from their magical incarnations. It's even worse once they grab hold of the boy, now you have to really mash the controller buttons in order to escape, if you take too long you will be taken into one of the mysterious blue doors and never seen again! I guess the closest comparison would be the sigils we see in Shadow of the Colossus, however in TLG there are many different types of icons, in SotC there's just one.
Archaic symbols from The Last Guardian
Sigil from Shadow of the Colossus
Overlords
All three games feature powerful overlords that are nourished in some way by dark energy. Players have long discussed if these entities are truly 'evil' but they definitely have their own agendas and don't seem to have a problem if other people (especially children) suffer the consequences of their laws. In Ico, the Queen sacrificed children in order to prolong her own selfish life, in Shadow of the Colossus, Dormin used Wander in order to escape its imprisonment, and in The Last Guardian, the enigmatic Master of the Valley somehow uses the life force of children (also sacrifices) to create guards and make more food for its Trico guardians. They all use the same dark energy as a power source which seems to glow with the turquoise (blue/green) light, the shadows eyes and horns and the black tendrils in SotC for example.
All three games feature powerful dark overlords
The Ending
I think most players of this game would agree that the ending was an amazing and emotional experience. Several popular Youtubers such as Pewdiepie and Jacksepticeye both were brought to tears at the end, I think most players (myself included) had a similar reaction. I'm not sure how many other games have elicited this response in players, some have said they felt an emotional response when Agro fell from the collapsing bridge in SotC, but compared to TLG's ending Agro's fall seems much less emotional in my opinion.
I think this is the first real example in the history of video games where a game can really move the player to tears, which is quite a leap when you think about it. Of course there are many movies that can move the audience to tears, but these are real people acting out real scenarios, video games are just digital pixels on a screen, so it's that much harder for a player to invest him or herself in a computer character.
The boy near death at the end
The great fear most fans had while we waited out the long years of the game's development was whether Trico would die at the end or not. I always said that the ending would be the same as Team Ico's previous two titles, that is it will appear the main companion character has died, but then will miraculously survive against all odds. This was true in Ico when it looked like Yorda went down with the Castle in the Mist, only to then wash up on beach, alive and well and hungry for watermelons xD. In Shadow of the Colossus, it looked like Agro died when she fell from the collapsing bridge but then later arrived limping to the Shrine of Worship, and in The Last Guardian it appeared that Trico was so badly injured after its outnumbered fight with the other Tricos and its strenuous effort to return the boy to his village, that it didn't have long to live.
Trico near death
But it appears my prediction was correct! But you have to wait until after the staff roll ending credits to see what happened. This is what I think happened after Trico delivered the boy to the village. Trico managed to fly back to the Nest and found a place to rest up and heal. Some of the armoured Tricos might have died once the Master of the Valley had ceased transmitting its homing beacon, but we have to remember that our Trico fell a 'long' way down into the Nest when it was hit by lightning and survived, so perhaps most of the other Tricos also survived? Trico could have mated with any one of these, but based on the final cutscene, the camera pans in on one particular Trico, which is the same one we had to fight earlier in the game.
If you remember, the boy pushed a heavy metal trolley down onto its head, breaking off its helmet and one of its horns, it's eyes change colour from red to normal, indicating that its dark influence was inadvertently removed... a happy accident. So when the homing signal was transmitted, this Trico only had one horn to receive the signal and as such wasn't drawn up to the top of the tower like the other 'armoured' Tricos were.
The other armoured Trico survived the ending
Now comes the question, was our Trico a female? I'm not sure about this as both Tricos seem to have the same genitalia, that is they both have an anus above and below a vulva urinary tract opening. I know this is an uncomfortable subject, but in order learn the truth we must make a detailed study of both Tricos' sex organs.
Our Trico's genitalia - you can see it has two openings
The other 'armoured' Trico's genitalia - again two openings
Other Trico appears to have 'teats'
But our Trico has no teats
One user on GamesF&Q (burqawitz) mentioned he had seen a number of teats on the other Tricos underbelly, so I checked this in my last playthrough and indeed I found this to be true! The other 'armoured' Trico appears to be a female as it has what look like teats, our Trico does not... so we can only concur (until we have more evidence) that our Trico is indeed a male. This goes against the previous two Team Ico games, as Yorda and Agro were female.
Trico with its pups
So we can assume that these two Tricos, now both free of the Master of the Valley's influence can behave the way they were intended, to procreate and live together as mates. This is the last scene we are shown in the game after the credits, the camera pans back to the well where we (the boy) first woke up, suffused with the light from the top of the cave we see two green glowing eyes, then a pair of smaller eyes appear next to them... at first you might think this is Trico and its mate, but then we hear the high pitched yelping of what sounds like pups! Grief is transmuted to joy ; ) Trico is alive and well, indeed thriving with its mate and pups in its old habitat. It's interesting to see that it chose this location to raise its pups, perhaps it had a strong connection to this place due to its memory of the boy and the adventures they shared?
Update: It appears there are actually three pairs of eyes in the final cutscene but you have to look very closely to see them. This would imply that our Trico is the one on the right (as you can make its horns glow by pressing the CIRCLE button), the pair of eyes on the left could be Trico's mate, and the smaller set of eyes in the centre might be the baby Trico? See high-res image here: http://imgur.com/7Qawrju
A third pair of eyes between the other two - hard to see
Timeline
I've not yet formulated a concrete timeline of the trilogy... my initial feeling is that The Last Guardian may be the first chapter in the trilogy, then Shadow of the Colossus, then Ico. My reasons for saying this is based on the entombed giant we first encounter in the mirror room. It seems to me that if this is indeed Dormin, or what was the precursor of Dormin, it received its life force from the Master of the Valley, which may have been an artificial intelligence or some kind of advanced program that held the entombed giant's mind and consciousness. It's no coincidence that in the final cutscene GenDesign makes a point to home in on this giant's tomb - there must be a reason for this! It seems this entombed giant is very special and may be the central nexus for the entire temple 'Nest' complex.
Entombed giant as shown in the final cutscene - very important to the story
But what happened after the Master of the Valley was destroyed? We have no way of knowing of course, but perhaps its demise initiated the giant's awakening? There must have been a failsafe device built into the Master of the Valley, if and when it was destroyed its accumulated knowledge would be sent back into the entombed giant as a last resort. Perhaps this was the trigger that finally made it possible for the giant to awake, after centuries of being asleep? The Nest was now devoid of all life except for the remaining Tricos, all the guards would have evaporated into nothingness once the Master of the Valley was vanquished, so in effect you would have another version of the forbidden lands, with nothing but the colossi (Tricos) and other minor animals.
The 'Nest' temple complex devoid of life (image credit to CandykillerArt)
Note: CandykillerArt has updated this map with higher resolution and annotations! See Reddit link here:
This powerful spirit now looked for a new home, and found a hidden peninsula surrounded by ocean and occupied by primitive tribes... a fertile new land that it could exploit for its hunger for power and dominance. So begins the next chapter.
Note: There is also another theory which places the events in The Last Guardian 'after' Ico, that is SotC > Ico > TLG. This is based on the observation that the boy has no horns, suggesting the bloodline of the horned boys is now so diluted that only a small fragment of Dormin's bloodline is left, not enough to grow horns, but just enough for the Tricos to identify these 'special' children. We also have to consider how similar the Master of the Valley 'sphere' is to the globes seen in Ico above the main gates. As mentioned above, it seems the Master of the Valley is an updated version 2.0 of the Ico spheres.
The Last Big Secret
In Ico there was a special 'secret' room that could only be used once you had hit a random tree with the sword. There was a false door on a wall that you could push open... the wall had a different texture to the surrounding walls so it was a clue. Even then, you had to find the tree outside of the room and then swipe at it many times with the sword in order to make contact, at which time a large metal ball fell down out of the tree to the ground. You then had to pick up this ball and take it to the room, and throw it into a large metal container to claim your reward! Which was the mace in the NTSC/US version, or the lightsabre in the PAL version.
Secret room and item in Ico
In Shadow of the Colossus the special secret was climbing up to the Secret Garden which required the player to have a massive grip meter in order to accomplish this feat. Once there you realised that this beautiful garden paradise was the same thing we saw at the ending cutscene, where Agro and Mono with baby Wander in her arms travelled to.
Secret garden in Shadow of the Colossus
But in The Last Guardian, we have yet to find such a significant secret... if you hold down the CIRCLE button at the final screen of the end cutscene (that is after the end credits) you will see our Trico's horns glow. Could this be the 'big secret' in The Last Guardian? If so, it's a disappointing 'big' secret in my opinion. Both previous games had secrets based on hidden or inaccessible areas, that's what us fans want, not a mere push of a button, but a cleverly hidden off limits room or cave etc.
Last Guardian 'easter egg' at the final screen of the game
So I'll keep on searching, perhaps in vain for a secret location. Perhaps it's something we haven't considered yet, like climbing down Trico's tail to an unseen (off limits) area? It appears there may be a few places that might be accessed by this method... only time and the diligence of players will tell ; )
I'm so happy reading you writing about TLG. Loved the comparisons, theories, I hope we keep discovering new stuff related to this new chapter... or.. initial chapter. Great entry as always. Greetings from Argentina
ReplyDeleteThanks ; ) Glad you enjoyed it.
Deletenomad wander is not dead because if you are open the art book you will see wander with mono in photo and wander look order then end of the game .
DeleteJust correct
Great post Nomad, Keep it up! :D
ReplyDeleteFirst I heard of the tomb being for Dormin. Reading this from the wiki is very interesting.
ReplyDelete'Dormin is possibly a misconjugation of dormit (it sleeps) or play on the Latin word dormiō, which means sleep. Dormiēns is the present active participle of dormiō. Dormin's powers remain locked away in the Forbidden Lands, where he rests in the shrine waiting to be awoken by one who possesses the Ancient Sword to awaken him and bring forth his resurrection. Thus it can be assumed that it is intended that Dormin refers to themself as "The Sleepers" or "The Sleeping".'
It makes me wonder if they tried to play off of this, but then we end up with even more questions. How did Dormin come to be, what is he, and if that is him, then how did he escape from The Valley? Maybe he has wings or something like he does in the SotC ending when he takes over Wander? But then it makes you wonder if The Master of the Valley might have created him, but that begs the question of where did The Master come from? Maybe he's from an even more ancient civilization, or alien made?
This game is the most mysterious of the three I think, yet the story is the most narrated. I know when I was playing I kept thinking of how much more simplistic the storytelling was, and feeling like the mystery wouldn't be like the previous games, and then The Master shows up and flipped everything on it's head.
I know TLG was probably the most emotional game of the three. I haven't felt like that since playing Journey. I like Shadow of the Colossus more, but all of Ueda's games will have a special place in my heart.
Sorry for a double comment I just read up about the tomb being for The Master of the Valley? So maybe The Master of the Valley becomes Dormin, he's trying to build himself a vessel? I think I like that idea a little more.
ReplyDeleteAs always, well written. I do wish to point out that the player actually does use a colossus to reach a higher platform in SotC. It is required to get atop the gazebos in #12's fight. And I believe you climb moss outside of just the Shrine of Worship, on the way to #1.
ReplyDeleteI respectfully disagree about the ending to TLG being the most emotional of Team Ico's games. Don't get me wrong, the ending was done very well, but I don't think anything will ever compare to the feeling I had when I believed I had killed my only companion in SotC.
Overall, I enjoyed TLG, but I would call it the team's weakest game. It certainly had a clever twist, putting the player in the helpless position, but I found it to be a bit too similar to Ico in terms of story and gameplay.
Thanks, I did think about mentioning #12's gazebos, but in TLG you move from one area to another on Trico so the comparison isn't really the same as at #12's lair you are bound to that arena until the colossus is killed. But I forgot about that small patch of moss at #1's area, although it's only there for tutorial purposes, I'll update the post ; )
ReplyDeleteI also agree that I like Shadow of the Colossus more, just wish there was more I could do with it - need another preview version or rare demo disc xD.
I can't imagine what you must feel towards SotC. You love it so much, but there's almost nothing left for you to find in it...
DeleteHere's to hoping that one day an earlier demo will leak, with some cut areas (or even colossi) in it :P
Hey Nomad,
ReplyDeleteI put a really small post up on the TLG subreddit (https://www.reddit.com/r/thelastguardian/comments/5mtsfs/spoiler_has_anyone_noticed_this_ico_link/)
I didn't really know where to go with the idea, but have you thought about the similarities between the Master of the Valley, and the Orbs in Ico, that open the Gate & Freeze Yorda?
Sorry if this has already been discussed somewhere else.
Don't know why the weird spacing happened. Sorry about that!
DeleteI replied on Reddit, but you made a great observation there! I can't believe I missed that... makes me rethink my ideas about the Master a bit, but I'd definitely like to add that to the above post.
DeleteAbout the spacing, it's because of the long link which takes up a whole line, so the other words are justified to fit on the first line which is why they are spaced out like that. It should all be left aligned but for some reason its justified.
Okay, two things I want to mention:
ReplyDeleteFirstly, I think that The Last Guardian's soundtrack is awesome, just as the soundtracks for the two previous games were. I have no favoritism for either of them, they're all amazing.
Secondly, I think you may be wrong about all of the mind-controlled Tricos dying at the end. Because if you think about it, our Trico which we first encounter fell from similar heights after being struck by lightning and managed to survive and recover. Therefore, it should possible for those brainwashed Armored Tricos to survive similar falls and make a full recovery. Of course, that's my take on that situation.
I'm with you. I actually didn't realize that the Trico you see at the end was the one you fought earlier. I thought it was just supposed to be a random one indicating that the Tricos survived. And I love Tricos, so I was quite saddened to hear that others thought they all died :(
DeleteThank you. Also, if you think about it, the manner the Master of the Valley controlled all the Tricos in doing its will to have all those children devoured very much resembles a level of animal abuse. In that aspect, I think The Last Guardian conveys a message of how we should NEVER mistreat and abuse animals, whether they be domesticated or wild.
DeleteGood point, I hadn't considered that. Makes sense that more than one Trico survived! But this is what I love about making a blog post like this as I'm always interested in the feedback I get which brings to light a lot of stuff I had missed or didn't even notice.
ReplyDeleteIndeed. You have also forgot to point about any references to the idols within TLG. For example, if you observe the architecture throughout the nest, you'll notice that there are some brick layouts on some of the walls that resemble faces, which I've interpreted as idols. Further more, those Trico statues litter throughout the game and the bird hatchling at the top of the white tower where all the children's bodies are deposited would also be considered idols as well.
DeleteI love to read your round up!
ReplyDeleteBut i would like to state that I think that it is the head piece that controlls the Tricos. Our Tricos Head Gear was damaged badly by the ligthning struk so he isn't under the controll of the master anymore. This also saved the second trico of which we destroyed the head gear in the battle with the wagon we dropped on it. As it loses interested in the fight after losing it and escapes. The other tricos may have alle gotten a head fry after we destroyed the master and he "outcries" with his last power. Indicated with the flashing in the geared tricos eyes.
This flashing also occured as we show our trico the shield, he "binds" with the shield. This binding was broken through the first cagelike structure that overtook trico by force. So we could later "rebind" trico to the shield after we got it back.
I also think the master of they valley lies in the sarcophacos where he was buried with the shield along. As the shield grants power over the tricos.
I don't know it the cage like structures are for conditioning of the tricos... but they seem to send on another frequence or it is because trico is so near to them that he is under influence of them as the outcry of the master didn't seem to bother him later on.
For the timeline i suggest it is after the first two games as still are special childs searches... and i think the children are "horned children" but the bloodline is thin. So that after that many generations they don't grow horns anymore but still have dormins power in them. (I would like to state that only boys grows horns as else it won't be possible to have any boys anymore with that bloodline)
I don't think that Tricos disolve to earth... as gen Design featured skeletons on their website from Tricos.
When Trico eats a barrel his eyes turns in the exact same way that some of the colossus with that green shine similar to the archaic symbols
ReplyDeleteI've read your analysis of the games a long time ago, and since TLG came out I was excited about reading this. I hope Mr. Ueda will share some more info about TLG because I think this game hides more than we can even imagine. Also I agree about this being the first game of the trilogy, but who really knows.. maybe we are paying too much attention to horned children and forget there is so much mystery around Yorda too
ReplyDeleteWonderful analysis and pictures! I watched someone else play TLG on Youtube since I sadly don't have a PS4, and I was so very curious about the last scene with the sarcophagus. I wondered if it might have a connection with Dormin, but from forums/posts I've read so far no one really talks about it and I was sad haha. I'm glad you mentioned it! It does seem very important since the game ending went through the trouble of showing us a solo shot of the sarcophagus.
ReplyDeleteI myself haven't really settled on whether or not TLG would come before or after SoTC. I've read arguments for both sides and both sound plausible. TLG either woke Dormin after defeating the Master or TLG is after Wander's bloodline has thinned out so much that horns are no longer sign of the curse.
TLG hasn't been out for long, so here's to hoping other players will find lots of easter eggs that will help tie TLG to others in the trilogy!
Nomad, you are my hero. I love your work with Team ICO games, and I was so excited to play TLG and finish it (I did a few minutes ago) before reading your post. I hope we can all get some answers from Ueda because IMHO we can't know the real truth of this trilogy without some oficial explanation... And sadly, I'm pretty sure that Team ICO will not make another game for this saga.
ReplyDeleteHi, Nomad. Regarding the image of the sphere atop ICO's main gate, from what point in the game is that particular image taken? I've just looked through all the cutscenes in the game and can't find that shot - where the cage which surrounds the sphere is half open like that. From looking more closely at these orbs in ICO, they appear to be made of stone - or some other mineral - with the markings carved into them, which leads me to believe they may be representations of whatever being The Master of the Valley is, rather than other examples of the being itself. From the image of the sphere in ICO you posted, this mineral nature isn't apparent, but from other scenes in the game it is more clear. They seem to become charged with energy and glow once activated.
ReplyDeleteBesides this, I also noticed other spheres in TLG besides the one near the glowing pot puzzle. In the area where you are separated from Trico and encounter the sleeping evil Trico, there is a globe suspended near the roof amongst the wooden rafters in a half-cage casing, with other empty casings also suspended nearby. More strikingly though is the sphere in the hollow tower behind this room which you pass through to escape from evil Trico. It's suspended real high (you have to look all the way up with the camera) almost at the opening at the top of the tower where there is another cage like casing covering the aperture. It's placed so far out of sight but so specifically.
The designs on these spheres seems different, too. They almost look like globes, with continents, but I can't get a close enough look at them to tell.
I think that take the rock spheres of ICO as a clue to speculate That TLG events come later is incorrect, 'cause if we follow this sillogism we must assume that SOTC comes after ICO events just because we see the Phalanx Sun-circles for first in ICO. For me is most reasonable think that the Queen tooks some inspiration from the Master of the Valley's mood to build her castle.
ReplyDeleteI just found out something incredible (from IMDB): "In early production, the unnamed was going to be a girl, but because of all the climbing and jumping players would have to do, and the possibility of up-skirt views, it was decided to go with a male character."
ReplyDeleteAnother thing, regarding our Trico having no teets: may not have matured enough to properly develop them, so it could still be female.
ReplyDeletethat last comment you made about the big secret is really petty. You got an amazing game, one in a lifetime experience, and you angry that the devs didnt insert a big secret for you? Come on.
ReplyDeleteI get it, alot of the reasons why you enjoyed Shadow of the Colossus was because of how many secrets it had to offer you, but expecting that to be the same and that being the reason why you go into it?
I didn't say I was angry, just disappointed - I'm sorry if you think that's petty. But after 7 years of waiting I had hoped for something special, as in a secret area, not just a minor easter egg.
ReplyDeleteThis was a great read! So in depth and very interesting.
ReplyDeleteI'm finally able to play the game again. I still feel like this game is hiding a few secrets, but maybe it isn't. Maybe they didn't have time to add in a secret or two after all that development hell. But still crossing my fingers.
I am also conflicted on whether this game takes place first or last in the trilogy, but I feel like it taking place last makes it a bit more interesting. Just like the queen, there are still entities out there trying to gather power in any way they can, even by kidnapping children in the night with their flying birdcatdog slaves.
I really find the connection/hypnosis thing that we saw between the boy and Trico so interesting. How is the Master able to find these children, and if it's not the Master, why are the Trico able to find them? There must be something about this boy as he seemed very reactive to Trico's approach. He even commented that he was dreaming of flying through darkness at the very beginning of the game. While it does appear to be a "taking a thorn out of the lion's paw" story on the surface, I feel like there's something more.
I also saw another easter egg kind of deal (or at least, it was an easter egg to me). At one point in the game (it's the area where that fallen Trico statue is, where the train car is caught under the gate and Trico sits down and refuses to move until you feed it) there is a dark room that you can barely see. Once you get Trico through, his eyes glow teal/green and guides you through the darkness. He looks very much like Dormin to me in that moment. His figure is almost completely black and nothing is visible except his eyes and horns. Very cool.
Just a thought on the gender, I always referred to Trico as a she, just sort of naturally, but doesn't the old man (old boy?) refer to it as a "he" in a piece of dialogue? I remember him saying that and being like "whatever, my Trico's a She, dammit!"
ReplyDeleteLove the blog! I had a few theories or ideas to bring up.
ReplyDelete1. I just discovered the windmill and found out you can destroy it. Perhaps this is the first step in a chain of events to unlock something? Or probably just for show.
2. Perhaps the mirror was melted down and made into the sword from sotc?
Also wanted to ask do you think the mirror room is inside of the base of the white tower? It seems like it is since it's the only place that is freezing and has the white design, but when you first get out of the cave and see the white tower it doesn't really look like you traveled that far up. I'll have to sketch it out.
seems odd that theres no secret forbidden room or anything like that when you see how much they lifted from the older games. perhaps the entire game world is a forbidden garden.
ReplyDeleteNomad,
ReplyDeleteOne thing I'm curious about (and can't remember because it's been so long). In SotC, do we see complex metalwork in the architecture like we do in Ico/TLG (thinking mine carts, rails, gates, etc)? That may be a clue to the timeline if they are absent in SotC but present in Ico/TLG.
The gate/fence that spans the front of Avion's arena is metal - like wrought iron, and there are metal bars at Kuromori & Celosia's temples... but nothing as sophisticated as we see in TLG.
ReplyDeleteNomad! Did U watch carefully last scene? Theres 2 pair of eyes - it's even visible on photo U pick
ReplyDeleteGreat post! By the way, this might just be me, but I think Trico's horns grow over the coarse of the game
ReplyDeleteI bought the game, and I still have the frame issue but I dont mind, I dont finish the game yet, but I found the Shadow of the Colossus lizards in the game and still looking for secrets.
ReplyDeleteTwo interesting things:
ReplyDelete1. In the mirror room with the giant tomb. If you look on the walls where the apparent doorway is you can see that the textures don't mesh well. It's almost as if they intended it to be a room but poorly covered it up with wallpaper. Every other room and area in the game there is great detail where wall textures seem to flow smoothly, but not here. Even in the same room the wall textures go together fine with the markings and color white, but at that intention in the wall the textures look odd.
2. Throughout the game there are square tiles on walls and buildings that are oddly brighter than others. I don't have a picture but I'm referring to the squares with a diamond shape on them (not the tiles that scare trico but actual wall tiles)
I actually just put up a pic in tlg subreddit asking if anyone noticed or knew what the diamond squares where. I was curious too, and they stood out.
Deletethanks Nomad for your detailed article, we were waiting for it.
ReplyDeleteI just would like to note that the idea of Mono being the love of Wander might not be accurate.
If you remember when she woke up and saw Argo, she had no reaction at all.
Imagine if you woke up after being dead in a strange place and you see your lover's best companion, his horse, you must be at least excited and maybe run towards him and pet him and ask him about his master (wander), but she did nothing of that.
Hello! I really like your blog!
ReplyDeleteOn the subject of "the call of nature," I think Trico's poo balls are the same as the spheres that cover the children. The two are greenish
,translucent and full of liquid. When you get the trophy, the voice-over of the narrator says that the "great secret of the tricos" has been discovered.
The substance of the barrel forms balls in the stomach wrapping what there is and if nothing is expelled without more. That's why the boy is full of tattoos after being swallowed by trico. The balls with a child inside regurgitate, normal way to feed some birds to their young. Totally agree with you on the stone figure simulating a nest at the top of the white tower, it's a trico baby!
As for the entombed giant, I believe that it is precisely “the Master of the Valley”, who left his body in the sarcophagus and transferred his vital essence to the tower, creating the great sealed room where he kept the mirror (like the pharaohs, his mummy and his treasures). This explains why the game shows its image following the destruction in the white tower.
The Lord of the Valley was not part of the primitive city considering the size and design of the buildings, there are large doors and rooms suitable for tricos next to rooms, doors, stairs etc ... suitable for the size of the armor-and the child too) but not for the giants.
The old ruined city was hidden inside the crater, in fact only the white tower is visible from afar, and was defended by the tricos and by its army whose helmets take elements of the tricos like the horns and the beak-muzzle.
The giant-Master of the Valley enslaved and killed the inhabitants by turning them into the green substance what is inside the great cauldrons to maintain their life and their powers (that is why he continues to kidnap people), he built the great wooden walkways with rails, between the towers, to transport it to the great tower and placed the eyes of glass to keep away the tricos; Mentally controlled the tricos with the food-barrels, gave army uniforms a look of life to use in tasks within the city, as it was not adequate to their size. And in the end, when everything was ready, he got into the sarcophagus.
On the other hand, as a secret area, I would like to reach the small round forest that is above the battle tower with first trico, it seems that in the center of the forest there is something?... Have you tried to arrive?
I think you are the best, and I congratulate you for your magnificent analysis of these games that so many people have kept alive in the heart.
Hello, Nomad. If you don't mind me asking, do you have an email address? Because there is something VERY important I want to ask you in private.
ReplyDeletebeleriand68@yahoo.com.au
DeleteThanks! I'll send you an email ASAP.
DeleteAlso I noticed in the Ico and Wander costumes use the same foot sound as they used in Ico and SotC. Thats a cool easter egg.
ReplyDeleteHello, Nomad. I've just sent you the email, but I want you to know that I'm EXTREMELY nervous on whether you'll reply with a "yes" or "no" (I'm very much hoping for the former).
ReplyDeleteOne thing I've noticed that I haven't seen mentioned elsewhere is the positioning of the pool. In SOTC it is positioned with the opening facing Mono, in TLG the opening is facing the sarcophagus. Could be some kind of link there.
ReplyDeleteAbout the Tower - do you think it could be markings on the walls falling out? Even though we see something falling, the Tower is still there in the ending cutscene. I had the impression that those glowing symbols all over the Tower (and the mirror room) were powered by the Master of the Valley and crumbled once it/he was destroyed.
ReplyDeleteAlso makes me a little sad. I thought the thing in the sarcophagus could be some nice respected guy when I first played it, now I'm convinced it's evil - the sarcophagus is connected, somehow, with the Master, who enslaved the Tricos and kidnaped people to stay alive/functioning. Not a nice guy.
Remember, what I've put in this post about the Master of the Valley and the giant in the sarcophagus is just my own speculations - it's still early days for this game and I'm sure the fan lore will evolve over time as it did with Ico and Shadow of the Colossus.
ReplyDeleteBut perhaps you are not wrong in your original assumption that the buried giant is a 'good guy'. The fact that he (she/it?) was buried with the mirror might indicate that he didn't want it to fall into the Master of the Valley's hands? It's the one item that can destroy the MotV, so it makes sense that it was hidden away from it for millennia. Only by a freak earthquake did a crack appear in the wall which, much later, allowed to boy to enter and borrow it for a while ; )
Behind the blue doors is The Master of the Valley in a low res model.
ReplyDeleteHey! Hi! Hello!
ReplyDeleteDid you see that?!
http://www.ign.com/articles/2017/06/13/shadow-of-the-colossus-ps4-coming-in-2018
I did indeed! My Twitter and youtube channels started buzzing like an angry hornet's nest today xD. I was like 'WTF is going on ?' Then I saw the trailer - OMFG! This was totally unexpected and left field - no one saw this coming! Props to GenDesign for keeping it secret ; ) I just hope (against hope perhaps) that it's an expanded field with extra colossi, but that may be a fools hope : (
ReplyDeleteI'm really excited about this news and I sincerely hope this game would be a wonderful opportunity to implement all implicit ideas:)
ReplyDeleteI noticed something while surfing...8.18 minutes of video...There is a stone similar to the silhouette of trico...https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=d5c9oYtNuvw
ReplyDeleteon the right side
You mentioned the sex of our Trico - that it's a male. But in the post previous to this you wrote that the way our character refers to Trico is a female name.
ReplyDeleteCould it be that the males feed young Tricos, or something else?
Excuse me Nomad, but have you seen this, maybe it has something to do with the previous title
ReplyDeletehttp://www.ign.com/articles/2018/01/02/the-last-guardian-developer-possibly-teasing-new-game
so this is a major major reach and i was thinking about it during my marathon of the 3 games but if this takes place before SOTC what if the Tricos ARE the Colossi just from the past? like their bodies are somehow used or altered in some way and then armored to be the Colossi that would hold Dormin spirit or even then when they got his spirit they had alterations for each one, they have some small similarities as far as body hair and blood and they glow horns and eyes like tricos, and i mean hey if trico had a kid then how many more possibly survived and had their own and stuff
ReplyDelete